Man-Made

About the Author: Bobbie Barren is an undergraduate in Anthropology at California State University, Long Beach and participated in Justice In View in the Santa Ana immigration court. Bobbie’s research interests in cultural anthropology and digital ethnography. 

Abstract: Immigration court reveals the rule of law as an inconsistent, fatigued, and deeply human-made system shaped by routine procedure, discretion, and indifference. 

Keywords 
procedural discretion; bureaucratic fatigue, routinization

Citation 
Barren, Bobbie. 2026. “Man-Made.” Semi-Structured (Washington, D.C.), On Ethnographic Witnessing: Student Encounters with Immigration Court, vol. 1 (3). https://doi.org/10.57912/34028376 


I think of the rule of law as a forged tool,  
Hammered, it takes its form as a blade
Yet who decides how to hone its edge?  

In immigration court, judges hold its handle 
To shape
To sharpen
To chip away 

I thought court procedure would be fairly tempered
Welded and fused together
A structure meant to keep justice steady.
I naively listened to the sounds of construction
And believed them deliberate, 
Methodical,
Consistent.  

 

But inside the courthouse,
the structure
Bent
It looked less like a work of intentional design
As a constant conveyor belt of demands grew
Procedure is not a structure
Rather, it's a factory
Where Justice shifts from a craft
To a quota

As the conveyor rages on
The edge changes
With each hand that holds it 

 

One judge demands a child's presence
Another does not.
One asks the respondent their native language
Another does not.
One is patient
Another exhausted.

Yet the line–that’s not really a line–never ceases
Justice, meant to be methodically built
Becomes reduced to process
Another case
Another file opened.
Another person called forward.

There’s a regular rhythm to the factory
Even as those it handles
May never experience this as ordinary

A job people leave at the end of the day 
“Happy Friday,”
“Have a good weekend!”
And sometimes gossip becomes the easiest thing to say.
“Judge said she’d be out by 4… it was 4:15.”-
A small laugh passed between an interpreter
And a clerk
“That’s early for her!”
They hiss.
A judge glances at a thick blue case file and sighs: 
“The bigger the file, the more I hope
for a failure to appear.”

The blade dulls under repetition
Fatigue settles into the hand that holds it

I was there only as a witness,
and saw the factory behind it–
The conveyor
The tools
The hands that keep it moving.
Here I understand

That none of it was inevitable
It was wholly man-made. 


About the issue 

This article is part of On Ethnographic Witnessing: Student Encounters with Immigration Court, a special issue of Semi-Structured. This collection features the work of 22 student ethnographers, who offer insights, analysis, and experiences based on hundreds of hours in immigration courtrooms across the country over the last few years. Through their work in observation projects under the direction of scholar-activists Lauren Heidbrink, Amelia Frank-Vitale, and Rebecca Galemba, students gained critical training in ethnographic practice and a crash course in immigration law, especially in the disjunctures between law on the books and law in practice. Understanding that wider audiences would benefit from hearing and learning directly from their students, Heidbrink, Frank-Vitale, and Galemba approached Semi-Structured to steward this thoughtful, ambitious collection. We are honored to run this issue and invite readers to consider what student observers witnessed, felt, and learned in court and why ethnographic observations are important to broader publics.    

Semi-Structured is the open-access journal from the Public Ethnography Lab. The journal is dedicated to showcasing ethnography as it unfolds in the world. This journal exists because we believe ethnographic work matters beyond the academy—that the insights generated through sustained engagement with communities, organizations, and institutions can and should inform decisions, shape practices, and drive meaningful change. 

Previous
Previous

You have the right to an attorney — but not at government expense

Next
Next

Performative Due Process: Opacity and Structural Coercion in Colorado’s Immigration Proceedings